israeli politics

How do you prepare for Purim when you’re in the middle of the story – the part where all the Jews are going to be killed?  On King George Street today in Tel Aviv, there were costumes, very sexy costumes, all over the streets, and the streets were full of people.  But the mood wasn’t joyous – it was defiant.

  

purim preparations – march 15, 2024 Read Post »

israeli politics

Boy, did I have a problem with statistics..  When I was studying psychology at the U. of R. I had to take a course, and I was failing – with a 25% average on quizzes.  In desperation I turned to my brother who pointed out that the whole course was about five equations and  once I could see which one had to be used I’d be fine. 

I aced the final, got a c in the course, which brought down my status on graduation from highest honors, but taught me that statistics could be my friend.

To the point:  We’ve been wondering about the statistics of Gaza deaths all along – how on certain days when not much was going on anywhere the numbers were the same as the day before, how some days of heavy battle few men were killed but a lot of children, etc.  Now Tablet magazine has pointed out how the rates are impossible to trust.  Check it out here:

I worked through the stats, and yes, he’s right. 

https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/how-gaza-health-ministry-fakes-casualty-numbers

 

 

 And them I raced to Ezi with the data, who barely blinked and said:  “How do you suppose they could be gathering reliable statistics anyway?  What kind of system could they possibly have in the chaos of war?  Of course they make them up!”

And then it hit me.  I never saw that statistics exam that gave me a C average.  The professor probably just saw my other grades and realized I shouldn’t get screwed by the failure I deserved.  Or maybe he remembered me by my plea for understanding.  Or maybe I was prettier than I thought I was.  But in order for me to get a C in the course with an average of 25 (when the value of the quizzes was 50% of the grade) I would need a final exam grade of way over 100, right? 175 to be exact.

So now that I have presented my credentials to discuss the subject, let’s take a look at the statistics of deaths in Gaza.  Al Jaziera says “At least 31,184 Palestinians have been killed.”  They also say More than 25,000 women and children killed in Gaza.   This would leave us with 6,184 men killed.  The US government seems to have adopted these statistics, making them seem more reliable. 

IDF however says it killed some 1,000 terrorists inside Israel on October 7 in addition to the 12,000 killed in Gaza since. There are no bodies because of course they have been buried, but doesn’t it make sense that if we are fighting hand-to-hand and face-to-face, we know more about how many fighters have been killed?

 

statistics – March 14, 2024 Read Post »

israeli politics

goes unpunished.  For years I’ve admired the struggle of the individuals and organizations who endeavor to transcend politics and to act in a humane manner – friends who drive to the border to pick up Palestinians and take them for treatment in Israeli hospitals, for example.  Usually the treatments are complex and unavailable except in very  specialized centers.  I cannot imagine how many people have died since these volunteers have found it difficult to sympathize after October 7 and do not participate in transporting and accompanying Palestinians, even after the government has begun to allow it again.  The revelation that some patients also planned terrorist attacks came out long before that but didn’t stop the volunteers.  But the mutilation in the massacres made it more difficult to sympathize.  Joanna Chen published a piece in Guernica about the renewal of her ability to empathize and return to her volunteer activities – and the journal was forced to remove the article because of objections at the ‘blatant zionism.’   

In short, there is no way a Jew – especially one living in Israel – can come off as a human being. 

no good deed – march 13, 2024 Read Post »

israeli politics

I’m sure I’ve written about Derijat before.  Years ago we visited this Bedouin village in the desert and were absolutely enthralled by their individuality, their persistence, and their great achievements.  We visited the school, the visitors’ hall, the cave a family originally lived in, and a few other places.  We learned about how they managed to achieve government recognition and how education was their highest goal. This time we went there and the same host told us about the village – and it is still enthralling.  But suddenly I wasn’t sure it was real.  Maybe it is just me in a fake news world.   Sometimes I can be so wrong.   I’ll have to work on learning more.  

This is what they wrote about back in 2004

https://www.haaretz.com/2004-05-20/ty-article/founded-in-1850-recognized-by-the-state-in-2004/0000017f-dc32-db22-a17f-fcb37aa40000

 

 

Derijat – March 12, 2024 Read Post »

israeli politics

I’ve had to take a break from the news – Just the fact that the terrible situation of the poor Gazans could be relieved if only the hostages would be released.  I think of the girls who are in their fifth month already, the 134 hostages – how many are still alive – and I can’t bear fighting  the ignorance, the indifference, the blind hatred.  Sure, we have done so many things wrong I can’t begin to count them, but we were the ones attacked, we were the ones too stunned to figure out what to do at first, and now we’re getting blamed for all the troubles in the world.  This is a great country and it deserves all the defence it can get, but I need time out. I’m going out to the desert tomorrow for the day.

 

 

too much – march 11, 2024 Read Post »

israeli politics

amazing how so many of our conversations around the dinner table are concerned with where we will hide.  One has a smallish shelter in her apartment that will do no good in a real rocket attack, one has no shelter at all but can go downstairs in the hallway, another has an apartment under the roof near an army base and will have nowhere to hide.  Me I cling to my shelter and am trying to figure out how I can house the whole family in a pinch.  Water, mattresses, pillows, blankets… it’s going to be hell.  

family conversations – march 9, 2024 Read Post »

israeli politics

MY HAMAN

Through most of my pre-teen years I got to play Haman in the Yiddish School Purim Shpiel. There were no tryouts for that part – everyone wanted to be Queen Esther and there was vehement competition. It usually went to the dignified and lovely Gittel, while her sister Leah had the smaller and less attractive role of Vashti. Little Velvel always won the part of Achashverus and the part of Mordechai was played by different enthusiastic boys every year. And I always breathlessly awaited my opportunity to wrap my long black hair in a white turban, draw a luxurious black moustache and bushy eyebrows over half my face and strut my flagitious will all over the stage.

The backdrop of our little theatre was always the same, the bright-colored mural of muscular workers in gold and green fields that gave depth to the Socialist-Zionist speeches in Yiddish. Behind us the romantic sustaining dream of Israel, before us the haggard-eyed audience of survivors only a decade away from the Holocaust, and here on this stage of the Farband House – we are happy to present the story of miraculous survival from far away exotic Shushan. This, Ladies and Gentlemen, is a tale of arrogant and self-assured evil, of purposeless and powerful malevolence, and it is my duty, as the first minister, Haman, to show how close it can come to succeeding.

In those days I used to have a recurring dream – while my family is sitting about the dining room table on a Friday night or at the Passover Seder, singing prayers in unison, the door of our home bursts open and Hitler and his men storm in. I am small, manage to slide under the table, and witness the slaughter only from the thighs down. But when it is over, a pair of black boots halts before my hiding spot, one knee bends to the floor, and Hitler himself reaches out to me, a jar of poison in his hand. “Am I dead now?” I would ask myself, and force myself awake.

But on the stage, on the evening of the Purim Spiel, I was filled with bravado. I became the incarnation of all I feared. I played Haman like the villain of a silent movie, swaggering out from behind the red curtain with the certainly of the crowd’s approval, exaggerating every gesture with gleeful irony, curling my moustache and leaning out to the audience to whisper of my unprecedented success, my personal humiliation of the Jew, my infallible plans for world power.

It made that sudden moment of confrontation all the more cathartic. Taken from the stage bewildered and silenced, my role was over. No longer Haman, I peeked through the red curtains of the back room as all the other characters celebrated wantonly on stage. With what comfort I watched the gentle and brave Queen Esther reap the applause of the evening. And then, when I came out to take a bow, I pulled off my turban and let my long hair flow over the now bloody costume, as if to say, “I’m not dead – Haman is.”

 

my Haman Read Post »