The Encantadas
Karen Alkalay-Gut
Ezra Gut
Contents
I wouldn't want a paradise.
John and Bob and Sam Hall knew
it's too simple just to be
good, without judgments
to make every moment,
new encounters to encourage
revision and insight. Living
as I do, equidistant from
Armageddon and Gehenna,
and not all that far from where
the Bible places Eden
my dreams teeter
like a dinghy in high tide
but with no one shore in sight.
But dream I do
Take five-and-twenty heaps of cinders dumped here and there in an outside city lot, imagine some of them magnified into mountains, and the vacant lot the sea, and you will have a fit idea of the general aspect of the Encantadas, or Enchanted Isles. A group rather of extinct volcanoes than of isles, looking much as the world at large might after a penal conflagration.
-Melville
Sometimes
You’d do anything for a sunflower
What do you care how ragged it is?
Say you're in the usual line at the airport
because a terrorist is suspected
or someone wore an unknown sort of back brace
or the computer is not coordinating as it should
or the weather didn't go the way of predictions
And you've said something unforgiveable like
'Is this the way it should be?'
and the soldier suddenly gets jumpy about your tone
justifiably, you realize in retrospect,
And that sunflower, standing in some dustheap,
would have put your soul in place
better than any perfect rose
Indeed, there are seasons when currents quite unaccountable prevail for a great distance round about the total group, and are so strong and irregular as to change a vessel's course against the helm, though sailing at the rate of four or five miles the hour. The difference in the reckonings of navigators produced by these causes, along with the light and variable winds, long nourished a persuasion that there existed two distinct clusters of isles in the parallel of the Encantadas, about a hundred leagues apart…And this apparent fleetingness and unreality of the locality of the isles was most probably one reason for the Spaniards calling them the Encantada, or Enchanted Group.
--Melville
The tides move one way
the wind another
and enchanted islands
may rise from the earth
unannounced
as the pronouncement
of a demon
or simply a reminder
that the world is not ours
to comprehend
Schopenhauer and I are sitting in the dinghy
And he says, "Get that stupid grin off your face.
"Just because you've got the helm doesn't mean
you know where you're going. You don't even comprender
the lingo of the navigator, and you have no idea
where we expect to land."
I veer a little bit, unnecessarily, to straighten out.
I could go on this way all day, I say,
without a single doubt. See my pilot?
He shouts – Tortuga! – and points.
And there's nothing in the complex world
I care more about, than riding alongside Carlos
and tortoises all the way.
Calls out to his harem
Come away from those strange beings
emerging from the sea
But the females will not listen
insist on swimming out to us
cavorting and snorting
and seeking our eyes
welcoming us
Into a world of paradise
If only we agree
to ignore the rules
to make our own pleasures
to create our own connections
Both [Albemarle and Narborough islands] are covered with immense deluges of black naked lava, which have flowed either over the rims of the great caldrons, like pitch over the rim of a pot in which it has been boiled, or have burst forth from smaller orifices on the flanks; in their descent they have spread over miles of the sea-coast….
--Darwin
The oldest secrets
eternally pouring
from the center of the earth
confound us in their variety of exits.
Cracks and holes, chinks and faults -
varying temperatures alone - braid the surface.
One crevice seems to invite you in;
another warns something terrifying may emerge
if you dare put your finger
there.
And yet they look
The same
The old man
holds his woman’s hand
as they stand
on the bare volcanic shore.
“Can you imagine?
These waves have been lapping
just like this
for four million years!”
Behold:
a myriad of stars
appear in the equatorial skies
I don’t know the names
of what became suddenly visible
when the clouds parted.
I can identify only Mars
by its color, and a constellation
here and there.
But so many, so clear!
Numbering them
would be
beyond my daring.
The Frigate bird swoops
down from great heights
to steal the digested food
the simple Booby was feeding
to her surviving chick.
It is all so quick
she doesn’t grasp
what has occurred
and continues to look
as stupid as her name.
We spectators,
who want to believe
in compassion,
cannot grasp
that what has just occurred
will occur again
and again
that his laws
are far more ancient
than ours.
In no world but a fallen one could such lands exist.
--Melville
The illuminated stadium is below –
We are the cheering hordes
peering over the deck
calling to each other excitedly
as the creatures
unaware of the applause
perform Darwin.
A sea lion swallows a squid
to our unmitigated joy,
The pelican moves two webs from the dinghy’s path
reluctant to give up this spot where the fish
crowd to the light, then swims in the shadows
like Jack, waiting in the dark streets of London.
Then suddenly it begins running, a Jesus,
over the water, and the fish (poor prey) flies
in the air, skips over the water and escapes
While a pair of frigate birds, indifferent,
pass overhead.
Perhaps I was too far away
but I swear
I thought I saw
the dolphins smile
as one of them
turned a triple somersault
high into the air.
Were they showing off for our ship
like samba schools in Rio?
In any case,
we were right there,
sipping coffee on the deck
when they came by
to renew our day
Lasting sorrow and penal hopelessness are in no animal form so suppliantly expressed as in theirs; while the thought of their wonderful longevity does not fail to enhance the impression.
Melville
We have nothing in common
You look at me with the wisdom
Of centuries and I am born anew here.
The rocks on the coast abounded with great black lizards, between three and four feet long;
Charles Darwin
They are all over the island
black iguanas bellies down on the rock
with one hand on the other
like an Escher drawing
“If they are all cold blooded
what makes them so cling to one another?
What makes them touch
just five long fingers?”
“And these are all female,
sisters of the same rock!”
“There must be a frailness about them
that needs the comfort of others,”
I plead.
“Darwin did not make the only rules.
There must be other origins in deed.”
They do not seem to have any notion of biting; but when much frightened they squirt a drop of fluid from each nostril.
--Darwin
I don’t know who began this staring match.
I’ve been going through these walks like a normal tourist,
admiring colors, grace, sweet maternal gestures,
a lost pup, a fatherly booby, a thieving frigate bird,
anything that approaches
the human in its behavior. Like the fact
that they do not move when you come by,
sitting on the trail as if it had been made
for their own pleasure, a bench in paradise.
The iguana catches my eye
not like a lover but a wiser being,
in charge of Eden, and my curious gaze
a challenge
to his older authority.
But he does not agitate his head
as he would had I been a male
after his harem. He remains
still.
I listen to the Naturalist
discussing volcanic remains
and keep my eye on the iguana,
he on me. I move to one side.
something in that eye stays,
keeping me entranced.
I move back, watching.
He spits a wide spray forward and I jump.
The Naturalist explains
he is sneezing, releasing the salt
of the algae he’d consumed.
And I keep looking, sure
that if that iguana isn’t telling me
to get off his path
I’m an idiot and don’t deserve
to share his space at all.
The spray comes again,
Then again.
And I relinquish
all mastery.
No matter what
the learned Naturalist says,
three snorts from an iguana
and I know my place.
in a clear lagoon
Kisses the image in the pool
As if there is no one else
In paradise.
And truly neither fish, flesh, nor fowl is the penguin; as an edible, pertaining neither to Carnival nor Lent; without exception the most ambiguous and least lovely creature yet discovered by man. Though dabbling in all three elements, and indeed possessing some rudimental claims to all, the penguin is at home in none
-- Melville
The penguins of the Galapagos
hopping languidly
over the volcanic rocks,
seem like
Plato’s puppets,
imitations alone
of the real
penguins
in Antarctica.
Dingy and duck-beaked,
they appear still befuddled
at their strange surroundings
where the Humboldt current dropped them off
generations ago.
Almost waiting
for the boat to take them
back to their own country.
And the Booby, the crab,
the wild creatures in the dinghy
don’t help their refugee souls
feel one bit at home.
You should have been
King of Denmark
Ruthless and beautiful
you rule the restless creases
of your mound as if
all the other creatures
were not meant
to be.
His vestigial wings,
feathery combs widespread
to their fullest range --
Reaching out,
just to show us all
He is the king
of this rock.
The rocks on the coast abounded with great black lizards, between three and four feet long; and on the hills, an ugly yellowish-brown species was equally common. We saw many of this latter kind, some clumsily running out of the way, and others shuffling into their burrows….
Charles Darwin
Walking among the volcano holes
those little bubbles of petrified pudding,
Judy and I sit to rest on a shelf
facing the sea
chattering of the quandaries
of dressing our age
and what we can possibly do
with our nails.
We go on for a while
before we see
we are sharing our shelf
our talk
with a large
inconspicuous
Iguana
who is clearly
listening
attentively
and obviously
has much
to learn from us.
Now here is one iguana
with whom I can relate
His face white with age
inhaling the knowledge of us
with studied indifference
There will be another group
of tourists
along soon.
“All we must do
not to interfere
with natural selection
is return the Galapagos
to their pristine state,”
the environmentalist said
and I spun around to see
the irony, the smile.
But he was as grave
as if he knew his Darwin
and it read
like the Bible.
It’s something I have to learn
the idea of saving nature
not the individual.
When Fernando told us
about the group stoning a cat
because it had to hunt the birds to live
and was destroying the endemic balance
I flinched
as if it had been me
How can a lover
learn to kill
Seventy thousand goats were shot on Isabella Island
seventy thousand goats munching the greenery
seventy thousand goats devouring the food
of the local tortoises, endangered enough
without this famine.
Seventy thousand goats
found in the mountains because betrayed
by the Judas goats who found the males
who lusted after them, and brought the hunters too.
My lover has a friend who got the job
of hunting them, one after the other.
And they were all pleased
they had freed the isle.
Seventy thousand goats were shot on Isabella Island
seventy thousand goats eating the greenery
seventy thousand goats devouring the food
of the local tortoises, endangered enough
without this famine.
But then
they weren’t goats.
They hadn’t been brought there
by some humans
and survived
until humans
decided otherwise.
How the weird reptilian fear overtakes me,
even though it is clear the giant tortoise
trudging slowly in my direction,
means only good,
a kind of easy greeting in his eyes.
I move away, and when he turns toward me,
back off again, step behind the crowd,
primordially infantile.
It is only in a photograph, a poem,
That I dare cross the line.